Skip to main content

Comparing D'Amato in Houston and Matsuda in Osaka



As of right now the two fastest women's marathon times this year are the 2:19:12 American NR by Keira D'Amato at the Jan. 16 Chevron Houston Marathon and the 2:20:52 by Japan's Mizuki Matsuda at the Jan. 30 Osaka International Women's Marathon. Dr. Helmut Winter, in charge of the pace projection system used in Houston, wrote to JRN this week to point out that both women had almost identical splits at 30 km, D'Amato clocking 1:39:14 and Matsuda 1:39:15. Both women ran with male pacers, and both set new course records. How else did their runs compare?

Both started with almost identical splits, D'Amato in 16:25 for the first 5 km and Matsuda in 16:28. In D'Amato's case she more or less held that through 15 km with an average split of 16:25 before slowing on a section of the course that included its toughest hill. From 15 km to 30 km she clocked 50:00, averaging 16:40 per 5 km. But despite slowing she was never off her target of breaking Deena Kastor's 2:19:36 NR, her slowest projected finish time being 2:19:34 at 30 km. From there she returned to the kind of pace she had over the first 15 km, with splits of 16:28 and 16:26 to 35 km and 40 km and enough left to kick to the finish.

In Matsuda's case, after starting off on NR pace she immediately backed off, hitting 15 km in 49:42 for an average of 16:34 and holding steady with a 16:38 split from there to 20 km. Mizuki Noguchi's male-paced 2:19:12 NR wasn't that far out of reach, but the focus seemed to be more on beating Mao Ichiyama's 2:20:29 best, the fastest time ever by a Japanese woman on Japanese soil and the women-only NR. But after 20 km Matsuda returned to her opening pace, going 16:27 and 16:28 to 25 km and 30 km and her projected finishing time ticking back toward Noguchi's record. If she'd been able to hold that until the end she would have been close it, but after hitting 30 km she slowed progressively the rest of the way, ultimately missing both Noguchi's and Ichiyama's marks in 2:20:52.

It's interesting that Matsuda's split from 20 km to 30 km, 32:55, was almost identical to D'Amato's from 30 km to 40 km, 32:54. It's tempting to say that Matsuda went too early and that if she'd held off longer like D'Amato she might have held it together better at the end and at least found the 23 seconds to hit Ichiyama's time. That's probably true, but she did actually hold it together better than in 2020, when she ran 2:21:47 after going through halfway 3 seconds faster.




In that race the female pace crew was steadier, averaging 16:34 per 5 km through 25 km and never more than 3 seconds off that in either direction, while the men this time averaged 16:33 through 25 km with a range of 7 seconds in either direction. But after 25 km, even though she slowed dramatically this time every one of her splits was still faster than in 2020. Or, in other words, she died harder in 2020. 

Part of that is that she was on her own in 2020 after the female pacers stopped, while this time the male pacers stayed with her until just before the turn toward the stadium entrance. But even so Matsuda did show development this time, even if she didn't meet her pre-race goals. A little more reliable pacing help, a little more self-control at the part of the race where it's most needed, and she might be able to come closer to the kind of NR time shared by D'Amato and Noguchi.

© 2022 Brett Larner, all rights reserved

Buy Me A Coffee

Comments

Stefan said…
This is an interesting analysis. Mizuki Matsuda incremental improvements are a positive sign. In last year's Nagoya marathon I recall a similar scenario developed where she fell away from an incredibly fast pace early on. To be fair, the windy conditions that day did not help. Will she break the 2hr20min barrier or has she reached her limit? I think she can do it.

But for now, I'm looking forward to seeing what Mao Ichiyama can do in the Tokyo marathon in a month's time. Given her post Olympic form on the track and in Exidens, unfortunately, I'm not expecting a fast time. Has married life affected her performance? Does she still have the drive to compete at the highest level? Has she burnt out after achieving the goal of competing in the Olympics? I think she will qualify for the MGC race but her time won't be close to a PB. Regardless, we will find out soon and I can't wait.
EatAndRun said…
Houston had a strong wind. D'Amato was into the wind on her slower splits from 15k to 30k and then had the wind at her back from 30k to the finish. Her effort was a lot more even than the splits look.

Most-Read This Week

SGH and Logisteed Break CR at Last 2 New Year Ekiden Qualifying Races

The last 2 regional qualifying ekidens for the New Year Ekiden corporate men's national championships were held Sunday, the last time the qualifying system will be held in its longstanding form before switching to a single national-level qualifying race next year. In the Osaka-area Kansai Jitsugyodan Ekiden, SG Holdings bounced back from a 22nd-place finish at this year's New Year Ekiden to win in a 3:53:39 CR for the 7-stage, 80.45 km course off a trio of mid-race stage wins by fresh new recruits Hyuga Endo , Itta Tameike and Tomonori Yamaguchi . Otsuka Seiyaku was 2nd almost the entire way and made it under the old CR too in 3:54:30. Having lost Endo to SGH in a transfer this year, early leader Sumitomo Denko was 3rd in 3:55:14, with Osaka Gas 4th in 3:56:27. A bit of controversy hit the race with 5th-placer finisher NTT Nishi Nihon was disqualified for an illegal exchange on the first handoff. NTT's 2nd runner Benson Kiplangat was on the wrong side of the exchange ...

2027 New Year Ekiden Field

Following this past weekend's last 2 regional qualifying races , the field for the 2027 New Year Ekiden corporate men's national championships is set. The complete field with each team's region, average pace in its qualifying race and place in the 2026 New Year Ekiden are below. Although 6 of last year's New Year Ekiden top 10 are from the East Japan region, its apparent dominance of the rankings is also due to its qualifying race being significantly shorter than the courses used in other regions. Logisteed (East Japan) - 2:48.5/km (2nd) GMO (East Japan) - 2:48.8/km (1st) Sunbelx (East Japan) - 2:49.5/km (5th) Subaru (East Japan) - 2:49.8/km (13th) Fujitsu (East Japan) - 2:50.4/km. (10th) Yakult (East Japan) - 2:50.6/km (19th) Konica Minolta (East Japan) - 2:50.6/km (26th) Honda (East Japan) - 2:51.3/km (8th) M&A Best Partners (East Japan) - 2:51.3/km (40th) JR Higashi Nihon (East Japan) - 2:51.4/km (4th) NTT ExC Partners (East Japan) - 2:51.5/km - debut Press Kog...

Chelangat and Sato Win Kobe Marathon

Rainy conditions were expected to impact performances at the Kobe Marathon , but with warmer than usual temperatures it ended up being a fast edition of the 20,000-runner race. Favorite Antonina Kwambai  and debuting Ugandan Annet Chemengich Chelangat  led the way in the women's race, with top-ranked Japanese woman Kaede Hagitani  a short distance behind with a private male pacer on track to clear the 2:27:00 time standard for her to qualify for Japan's Olympic marathon trials next fall. 13 seconds behind Kwambai and Chelangat at halfway in 1:13:17, Hagitani moved up to catch them by 25 km, then tried to pull away. Kwambai dropped off, but Chelangat stayed right with Hagitani until Hagitani abruptly slowed just before 35 km. From there to the end she ran alone, winning her debut in 2:28:09. Kwambai held steady to run Hagitani back down for 2nd in 2:28:27, barely holding off a fast-closing Kotomi Tsubokura  who ran a well-paced race off a 1:13:55 first half to take 3r...