Skip to main content

Toyo University Overcomes Kashiwabara's Legacy With All-Time Second-Fastest Hakone Ekiden Win

by Brett Larner
photo by Kazuyuki Sugimatsu

click here for Hakone Ekiden Day One report and results

Before 2009 Toyo University had only finished in the top three once in the history of Japan's biggest sporting event, the Jan. 2-3 Hakone Ekiden university men's road relay championships, all the way back in 1960.  In Hakone's 85th anniversary running in 2009, the tens of millions of fans who watch Hakone live on TV and along its ten-stage, 217.9 km course were witness to the birth of a legend as Toyo first-year Ryuji Kashiwabara singlehandly lifted the team to the winner's podium for the first time with a stunning course record on Hakone's most celebrated stage, the 23.4 km Fifth Stage with nearly 900 m of climb.  With Kashiwabara Toyo was almost untouchable at Hakone; he won the Fifth Stage all four years at Toyo and set stage records on it in three of them.  Every time he broke the record, Toyo took the overall win, transforming themselves from the likable underdogs to the best of the best.  Kashiwabara's senior year in 2012 Toyo redefined Japanese collegiate distance running by taking more than 8 minutes off the Hakone course record, breaking both the Day One and Day Two course records and becoming the first team to average under 3 min/km for the entire 217.9 km course.  Team members said they wanted to give Kashiwabara the win without relying on him after he had given them everything for the three years before, and it's fair to say they succeeded in that goal.

But since Kashiwabara's graduation Toyo have been unable to overcome his legacy and prove that they are truly the best and not just a second-class team lucky to have had a once-in-a-generation talent in their ranks.  In every major university ekiden since Kashiwabara left, the 2012 Izumo Ekiden, 2012 National University Ekiden, 2013 Hakone Ekiden, 2013 Izumo Ekiden and 2013 National University Ekiden, Toyo came 2nd.  The teams that beat them were different every time, but as the competition came and went and Toyo's athletes continued to grow they could not find that something that would at last put them on top without the hand of Kashiwabara.

Finally, in what may be Toyo's last chance for a few years, all that changed today.

On Day One of this year's 90th Hakone Ekiden Toyo scored the win on the strength of stage wins from its star seniors, identical twins Keita and Yuta Shitara, in the second-fastest time ever behind only Toyo's own 2012 winning run.  In 2012 Toyo ran 5:24:45 with a 1:16:39 Fifth Stage record by Kashiwabara.  This year Toyo covered the 108.0 km Day One in 5:27:13, with captain Keita Shitara running the Fifth Stage in 1:19:16 to become its fourth-fastest man ever.  Fifth Stage aside, Toyo's first four men ran 9 seconds faster than they did in the 2012 course record, meaning that although Kashiwabara represented roughly a 2 1/2 minute advantage, as a team they were better than ever.

Riding the momentum of that knowledge, Toyo took complete control of Day Two.  With just a 59-second lead over 2013 Izumo Ekiden and National University Ekiden champion Komazawa University, every one of Toyo's five men on the 109.9 km Day Two ran to the limit of his ability.  Downhill Sixth Stage senior Keisuke Kusaka ran the tenth-fastest time ever on the 800 m-descent course to open the lead to 1:17, just under Toyo head coach Toshiyuki Sakai's requested 1:20.  Star first-year Hazuma Hattori, the younger brother of Toyo's Second Stage man Yuma Hattori, won the Seventh Stage in its seventh-fastest time ever, widening the lead beyond Sakai's 1:40 projection to 1:54, a critical blow to Komazawa's chances for its ace senior Shinobu Kubota to run them down on the Ninth Stage, Day Two's longest stage at 23.2 km.

On the Eighth Stage Toyo junior Ryu Takaku dealt Komazawa's hopes their coup de grâce, running the stage's all-time fourth-fastest mark to take Toyo's lead to more than a kilometer, 3:40 ahead of Komazawa at the Ninth Stage handoff.  Komazawa's Kubota did his best, the only man on his team to make up ground on Toyo on Day Two as he ran the Ninth Stage's all-time fourth-best time, but could only pick up 28 seconds on Toyo second year Kazuki Uemura.  Toyo anchor Kento Otsu inherited a 3:12 lead from Uemura, still over a kilometer ahead of Komazawa anchor Kenya Sonota, and could have played it conservatively, all but guaranteed of the win.  Instead, he set off at 100% for the 23.1 km anchor stage, more than a minute ahead of course record pace at 5 km.  Coach Sakai gently told him to relax and take it easy, but senior Otsu continued to go for the gold in his final university ekiden.  On track with 5 km to go, he began to tighten up and slowed just enough to miss the record, 9 seconds off the mark but getting the anchor stage's all-time third-best time.  For fearlessly going after the record when he could have played it safe, Otsu won the 2014 Hakone Ekiden MVP award.  More importantly, he got the win.

Crossing the line 4:36 ahead of Komazawa, an ecstatic Otsu brought Toyo home to its first university ekiden title since the Kashiwabara era, finally lifting the weight of the thought hanging over Toyo, the thought that it might have only been as good as was in those years because of one man.  Toyo's Day Two time of 5:25:38 broke its 2012 Day Two record by 1:13, its overall time of 10:52:51 for the full two-day race the second-fastest in Hakone history and only 1:45 behind 2012's record.  Less than half a second a kilometer.  It cut the distance to Kashiwabara almost in half and broke the 3:00 min/km barrier without him for the first time, its ten men averaging a 1:03:13 half marathon each and raising the possibility that, working together, they might some day rise to an even greater height than he took them.

Throughout the race coach Sakai called positive encouragement to his runners, telling them that they looked good, that they were going a good job, encouraging them to do more or asking them to hold back.  In post-race interviews Coach Sakai said that his message to the team this year had been for each of them to shave off just one second, whatever that meant to each of them.  Seventh Stage winner Hazumi Hattori said that the positive atmosphere and emphasis on enjoying running at Toyo was a big part of their strength as a team, that it was fun to be a member and that that was the secret of their success.  With stage winners Otsu and the Shitaras graduating along with excellent downhill man Kusaku Toyo won't completely surpass its Kashiwabara course record anytime soon, but its first win without him, its incredible quality, and the positive, encouraging atmosphere the team exudes under the young Sakai means Toyo will remain one of the best for the foreseeable future.

Compare this to the atmosphere at Komazawa, which this season became the Izumo Ekiden course record holder and scored an eleventh national title.  Throughout the race head coach Hiroaki Oyagi shouted and screamed things at his runners from a loudspeaker in his chase car that would get a coach in the NCAA fired.  After Day One, when Komazawa ran 5:28:12 to become the second-fastest team ever on the Day One course, he blamed star junior Kenta Murayama, who finished 2nd on the ace Second Stage, for Komazawa not winning the day.  On Day Two Komazawa ran one of the fastest performances in Hakone History to finish in 10:57.25 overall, faster than any school in Hakone history except Toyo, but hanging their heads in disappointed shame.  Defending champion Nittai University took 3rd in 11:03:51 to become the fifth-fastest school ever at Hakone and 2011 champion Waseda University likewise ran faster than all but four schools ever have, but there were no smiles to be found on either team.  Not until 5th-placer Aoyama Gakuin University, another school with a younger coach, Susumu Hara, with different ideas and an emphasis on enjoyment, tied its all-time best placing did another school look happy, anchor Ikki Takeuchi and his waiting teammates whooping and laughing as he came down the final straight.  As the level of Japanese collegiate running continues to climb rapidly, all 23 schools fielding runners with 10000 m bests under 29 minutes and most with at least one sub-63 half marathoner, many of the younger coaches with a kinder touch like Sakai and Hara seem to be the ones leading the way.

Meiji University, with eleven men holding 5000 m bests under 14 minutes, returned from a bad Fifth Stage to rise as high as 4th during Day Two but dropped to 6th over the last two stages.  Further back, the race for the seeded top ten was one of the best in memory.  Each year the top ten finishers are guaranteed a place at the following year's Hakone Ekiden, freeing them up to run October's Izumo Ekiden.  11th-place and lower teams must requalify against other schools hoping for Hakone glory at October's Yosenkai 20 km qualifier instead of Izumo.  This race to get into the seeded top ten bracket usually provides at least as much Day Two drama as what is happening up front.  This year six teams were in range of the last four seeded places in 7th-10th behind Meiji, at one point all within 18 seconds of each other.  The tense and turbulent battle between the six had nearly constant turnover over the course of the day.

Nihon University, 10th at the end of Day One, dropped out of the top ten briefly before coming back to 7th.  Last year's 4th-placer Teikyo University was running 12th, but after a great run by Ninth Stage man Taketo Kumazaki it moved up enough to repeat in the seeded bracket in 8th.  At one point Takushoku University first-year Tomofumi Uda, holding Takushoku steady in 8th, collided with a neighboring runner and fell hard, having trouble getting up and slowing badly enough to drop to 10th place, giving Takushoku a scare as he came just seconds ahead of 11th and the dead zone outside the seeded bracket before later runners got the team back up to 9th.  Daito Bunka University and Hosei University, missing its star runner Kazuto Nishiike who was injured Dec. 29 when he fell down a flight of stairs, staged a back-and-forth battle for 10th, Hosei anchor Hirotaka Takanashi bearing down on DBU's Ryo Onishi in the home straight but unable to close. Tokai University seemed a lock for a seeded finish after running most of the race well inside the cutoff but had a disastrous anchor run to drop to 13th. Yamanashi Gakuin University, out of competition after Second Stage Kenyan Enoch Omwamba suffered a stress fracture and was forced to stop but its remaining members allowed to run without their times counting in the overall scoring, ran the 9th-fastest time on the Day Two course, meaning it was in the action for most of the day even without actually being in it.  Along with the world-class times by Toyo and Komazawa up front, the dense and tense racing mid-pack showed the best of what makes the Hakone Ekiden the greatest of road races.

90th Hakone Ekiden
Tokyo~Hakone, Jan. 2-3, 2014
23 teams, 10 stages, 217.9 km
click here for complete results

Team Results
1. Toyo University - 10:52:51
2. Komazawa University - 10:57:25 - all-time #2
3. Nittai University - 11:03:51 - all-time #5
4. Waseda University - 11:04:17
5. Aoyama Gakuin University - 11:08:53
6. Meiji University - 11:10:09
7. Nihon University - 11:12:52
8. Teikyo University - 11:13:03
9. Takushoku University - 11:13:06
10. Daito Bunka University - 11:14:43
-----cutoff for seeded bracket for 2015 Hakone Ekiden
11. Hosei University - 11:15:33
12. Chuo Gakuin University - 11:15:40
13. Tokai University - 11:17:52
14. Tokyo Nogyo University - 11:18:02
15. Chuo University - 11:18:43
16. Juntendo University - 11:19:03
17. Koku Gakuin University - 11:20:44
18. Kanagawa University - 11:23:47
19. Josai University - 11:25:42
20. Jobu University - 11:25:56
21. Senshu University - 11:28:39
22. Kokushikan University - 11:38:35
DNF - Yamanashi Gakuin University

Day Two Top Stage Performances
Sixth Stage (20.8 km, ~800 m downhill)
1. Daiki Hirose (Meiji Univ.) - 58:16 - all-time #2
2. Masahiro Miura (Waseda Univ.) - 58:51 - all-time #7
2. Yusuke Suzuki (Nittai Univ.) - 58:51 - all-time #7
4. Keisuke Kusaka (Toyo Univ.) - 59:04 - all-time #10
5. Yoshihiro Nishizawa (Komazawa Univ.) - 59:22

Seventh Stage (21.3 km)
1. Hazuma Hattori (Toyo Univ.) - 1:03:27 - all time #7
2. Yusuke Ogura (Aoyama Gakuin Univ.) - 1:03:37
3. Yusuke Nishiyama (Komazawa Univ.) - 1:04:04
4. Toshikatsu Ebina (Teikyo Univ.) - 1:04:18
5. Toshiyuki Yanagi (Waseda Univ.) - 1:04:29

Eighth Stage (21.5 km)
1. Ryu Takaku (Toyo Univ.) - 1:04:35 - all-time #4
2. Yuki Arimura (Meiji Univ.) - 1:05:21
3. Daiki Numata (Chuo Gakuin Univ.) - 1:05:47
4. Shuhei Kitsukawa (Daito Bunka Univ.) - 1:05:50
5. Shoya Okuno (Nittai Univ.) - 1:06:07

Ninth Stage (23.2 km)
1. Keigo Yano (Nittai Univ.) - 1:08:29 - all-time #2
2. Shinobu Kubota (Komazawa Univ.) - 1:08:56 - all-time #4
3. Takuya Fujikawa (Aoyama Gakuin Univ.) - 1:09:23 - all-time #10
4. Kazuki Uemura (Toyo Univ.) - 1:09:24
(5.) Tatsumi Abe (Yamanashi Gakuin Univ.) - 1:09:46 - did not count due to YGU DNF on 2nd Stage

Tenth Stage (23.1 km)
1. Kento Otsu (Toyo Univ.) - 1:09:08 - all-time #3
2. Kenya Sonota (Komazawa Univ.) - 1:10:30
3. Renya Sugiyama (Teikyo Univ.) - 1:10:52
4. Shunpei Takamatsu (Nihon Univ.) - 1:11:05
5. Shota Kai (Nittai Univ.) - 1:11:10
(5.) Yuma Morii (Yamanashi Gakuin Univ.) - 1:11:10 - did not count due to YGU DNF on 2nd Stage

Day Two Team Results
1. Toyo University - 5:25:38 - CR
2. Komazawa University - 5:29:13
3. Nittai University - 5:30:06 - all-time #4
4. Waseda University - 5:31:55
5. Teikyo University - 5:33:40
6. Aoyama Gakuin Univesity - 5:33:49
7. Meiji University - 5:34:08
8. Chuo Gakuin University - 5:35:22
--- Yamanashi Gakuin University - 5:35:23 - did not count due to YGU DNF on 2nd Stage
9. Juntendo University - 5:35:33
10. Nihon University - 5:35:40
11. Chuo University - 5:36:16
12. Tokyo Nogyo University - 5:36:23
13. Takushoku University - 5:37:14
14. Hosei University - 5:37:47
15. Koku Gakuin University - 5:38:08
16. Daito Bunka University - 5:38:12
17. Senshu University - 5:40:42
18. Tokai University - 5:40:52
19. Josai University - 5:41:15
20. Kanagawa University - 5:41:51
21. Kokushikan University - 5:42:48
22. Jobu University - 5:43:57

(c) 2014 Brett Larner
all rights reserved

photo (c) 2014 Kazuyuki Sugimatsu
all rights reserved


Anonymous said…
Excellent comparison of the coaching styles between Sakai (and Hara) and Oyagi. Oyagi-san's military style of coaching worked well back in the day when kids were much more thick-skinned and used to constant nagging from their parents and teachers, but not anymore. Clearly, Toyo was much more of a 'team' than Komazawa. Komazawa's runners' strength in the early 2000s was their ability to dig deep and find something extra in the last 5km when Oyagi would yell over the loudspeakers. In my opinion this is the key to winning at Hakone. I would love to see stats of the time differences between all the runners for their last 5km. My guess is that there is a huge gap between Toyo and the rest. As a Komazawa supporter, it's painful to watch the disconnect between the coach and his kids. As you mentioned, Aoyama Gakuin is a team to watch out for and I expect them to contend for a title soon.
Brett Larner said…
I've had some questions on email about why there are a few gun starts with a small number of runners on a few stages. The answer:

If teams fall more than a pre-determined amount of time behind the leaders they have to start the
next stage at a particular time, usually with a white or other colored sash to show that they did not pass on the original one. The time difference between when they start and when the preceding runner comes in is then added to the running time.

The cutoff at the end of the Second Stage was 10 minutes, so at exactly 10:00 after leader Komazawa came through the last remaining team, Kokushikan, started the Third Stage (along with YGU which had been eliminated by Omwamba's DNF but allowed the honor of still completing the remaining stages without their times being counted). Kokushikan's second man came in at 12:10, so Kokushikan carried a 2:10 time handicap that was added to its total time at the end of the day.

The cutoff at the end of Day One was also 10:00, so every team that was further behind than that (11th~22nd place plus YGU, as it turned out) started Day Two at 10:00 behind leader Toyo and had the time handicap added to its running results. Most of the stages on Day Two have a 20-minute cutoff, so you had up to 7 teams starting at once on one of the later stages. It's down to the second, so even though two teams' runners were right there their next guys had to start on the gun.

Next to a DNF getting white sashed is the worst thing that can happen to a team in an ekiden because the continuity of the tasuki is broken, the piece of cloth that holds the sweat that symbolizes the efforts of the teammates that came before you is stopped and doesn't make it to the finish line. That's why you see the guys coming in who don't get to hand off crying and lying on the ground in devastation afterwards. They're not joking around or acting. Ultimately it's an issue of road closure permits and not all ekidens have it, but the white sash start rule definitely adds something to the event. If nothing else it creates an emphasis on excellence: if you don't measure up as a team you're going to wear a mark that shows that fact to everybody, and that's a shame they all want to avoid.
Brett Larner said…

I'd add Hosei's new head coach Tomo Tsubota, 36 and all-time Japanese #10 over the half marathon, to that list. Bad luck with Nishiike getting hurt this year but I'm expecting Hosei to increase in quality a lot over the next year or two.

I don't think I would totally dismiss Oyagi, though. He is still the most successful college coach Japan has, with the Izumo CR, 11 National University Ekiden titles including the last three years, and a time at Hakone this year that would have beaten every team ever except for Toyo in '12 and '14. But, winning Hakone does take something extra that Komazawa seems to have lost under him this generation, so you may be right to some degree.
wataru22 said…
Brett - (I wrote anonymous earlier)

I haven't totally written off Oyagi yet, but as a Komazawa supporter who was spoiled with the glory days 10 years ago, I guess I am getting a bit impatient with the 2nds and 3rds despite his superstar caliber runnes. I think he started having problems when he started to recruit the big names such as the Ugachi/Takabayashi/Fukatsu/Hoshi group. I still don't think he has gotten completely used to learning how to deal with superstars and as a result, his attention to the lower level kids has waned. All speculation of course, but that's what it looks like to me.

Also, in regards to up and comers, you can probably add Komadai alumni Maeda (Kokugakuin and Kamiya (Musashino Gakuin)to the list.

Most-Read This Week

The 2023 Hakone Ekiden Champs Komazawa University at the United Airlines NYC Half

2023 Hakone Ekiden champion Komazawa University 's 1st and 8th runners from its winning team Kensuke Tsubura  and Yuto Akahoshi were at the United Airlines NYC Half Sunday with head coach Hiroaki Oyagi and his wife Kyoko Oyagi as part of the partnership between race organizers NYRR and November's Ageo City Half Marathon set up by JRN in 2012. For both athletes it was the first time for them to ever go outside Japan. Akahoshi, a 3rd-year at Komazawa who ran his PB of 1:02:00 at Ageo last fall, lasted longer in the main pack, staying with the group that ended up filling 4th through 14th after the breakaway move up the East Side by world record holders Jacob Kiplimo and Joshua Cheptegei of Uganda and Moroccan Zouhair Talbi . In the last 5 km he dropped back to finish 14th in 1:03:49, just behind 2022 Fukuoka International Marathon winner Maru Teferi of Israel. "My goal was to come here and try to stay with some of the best athletes in the world, so I'm pretty disap

Where Japan's Paris Olympic Marathon Trials Qualification Is At

Last Sunday's Nagoya Women's Marathon was the last of the main chances for Japanese marathoners to qualify for the Oct. 15 MGC Race, the country's official marathon trials for the 2024 Paris Olympics. At the trials the top 2 finishers will be named to the Olympic team, with the 3rd finisher provisionally in and the 4th and 5th placers named provisional alternates. After that it's one last turn through the winter 2023-24 season of the big domestic races where people will have the chance to steal the 3rd spot on the team and bump the 3rd-placer at the trials down to alternate. The deadline for qualifying for the trials is May 31, and there are still a few smaller domestic races like this Sunday's Tokushima Marathon and April's Nagano Marathon, and overseas races with a World Athletics elite label or better where those who haven't qualified yet can try to make a miracle happen. But for the most part, almost all the real contenders are already in. 62 men and 29

Shinohara Wins National University Half Marathon, 215 Go Sub-1:06

Fresh off becoming the fastest-ever Japanese-born collegiate half marathoner with a 1:00:11 in Marugame last month, 2023 Hakone Ekiden champ Komazawa University 2nd-year Kotaro Shinohara won the National University Half Marathon Sunday in Tokyo's western suburb of Tachikawa. In warm conditions the dense lead group ran relatively conservatively, on track to go just under 63 minutes. But entering Tachikawa's Showa Kinen Park for a final 5 km of undulations and sharp turns Shinohara turned it on to pull away, winning easily in 1:02:16. Another of the pre-race favorites, sub-28 10000 m runner Reishi Yoshida of Hakone non-qualifier Chuo Gakuin University was 2nd in 1:02:29. Another Hakone non-qualifier, Tokyo Nogyo University 's Neo Namiki looked set to take 3rd. But in the last km Rei Matsunaga of Hosei University , famed for trying to run away with last year's Kanto Regionals 5000 m versus 3000 m SC NR holder Ryuji Miura , came up to pass Namiki, stealing 3rd in 1:0