Skip to main content

Shibui vs. Radcliffe and Akaba vs. Goucher

by Brett Larner

Although it is always difficult to compare performances in different races, the results of the top finishers in this past Sunday's Osaka International Women's Marathon had interesting parallels to those from November's New York City Marathon. New York's course is generally perceived as more difficult, but both courses feature significant up-down. Apart from New York's uphill start, both courses' major hills occur on the sections between 13 and 15 km and between 24 and 27 km, with rolling net uphill in the final 5 km. Osaka's course also has a significant hill at 31 km.

The first table below lists the 5 km splits for the two winners, Osaka champion and former national record holder Yoko Shibui (Team Mitsui Sumitomo Kaijo), and New York victor and world record holder Paula Radcliffe (U.K.). The second table lists the 5 km splits for Osaka runner-up Yukiko Akaba (Team Hokuren) and New York 3rd-place finisher Kara Goucher (U.S.A.), both of whom were running their debut marathons.

While the Osaka race held a relatively steady pace through 30 km, New York began slowly and progessively built up through 20 km. The pace slowed going over the 59th St. Bridge at 25 km, but after coming off the bridge Radcliffe accelerated, holding a higher tempo of 3:19-3:20/km for the next 10 km, accelerating to 3:17/km from 35-40 km, then fading to 3:19/km in the final stretch.

Shibui waited until nearly 30 km before picking up the pace from an average of 3:28/km to 3:14/km through 35 km, slipping back to 3:19/km through 40 km, then closing with her fastest splits, averaging 3:12/km for the last stage. Although Shibui's times led Radcliffe's until 25 km, the two runners' relative positions flip-flopped for the rest of the race with an identical clocking of 2:16:40 at the 40 km mark.

As another way of looking at the splits, both runners clocked 3:27/km for the hilly 5 km leading into their spurts. Shibui then dropped down to 3:14/km followed by 3:19/km versus Radcliffe's 3:19/km and 3:20/km splits for the two 5 km sections following the winners' attacks. Radcliffe timed her move earlier and had to run an additional 5 km at higher pace; whether Shibui could have gotten away with timing her surge earlier like Radcliffe and running the 25-30 km section through Osaka Castle 30 to 45 seconds faster is a valid question. Given the strength shown in her closing kick and the energy with which she jumped around celebrating her win, the answer is probably yes. Shibui's closing kick surpassed that of the world record holder and was all the more impressive for having taken place during sleet, making her prospects at this summer's World Championships very enticing indeed.

In the case of debutantes Akaba and Goucher, both runners stayed with the eventual winners until the big moves at 30 km and 25 km respectively. Each runner accelerated from 3:27/km pace to 3:19/km for the next 5 km, then by 40 km faded to 3:31/km in Akaba's case and 3:29/km in Goucher's. Like Shibui and Radcliffe's 40 km tie, Akaba and Goucher's 40 km marks were only one second apart. Again paralleling the winners, Akaba kicked back down to 3:27/km for the last 2.195 km during sleet while Goucher sank to 3:34/km, her slowest of the race apart from the leisurely first 5 km. Akaba finished 1:58 behind Shibui, while Goucher finished 1:57 behind Radcliffe. With both Akaba and Goucher debuting as part of a buildup plan to the London Olympics it will be interesting to track their development in coming years.

Nobby Hashizume of the Lydiard Foundation has another analysis of Shibui's performance here.

(c) 2009 Brett Larner
all rights reserved


Most-Read This Week

Tokyo Marathon Cancels Mass Participation Race, To Go Ahead as Elite-Only Event (updated)

Update: The Mar. 8 Nagoya Women's Marathon, the world's largest women-only marathon, is now also looking at canceling its mass-participation division.

In response to the spread of the coronavirus within Japan, the Tokyo Marathon Foundation has decided to cancel the Mar. 1 Tokyo Marathon's 38,000-runner mass-participation race. Founded in 2007, the Tokyo Marathon is Japan's largest mass-participation marathon, with more than a million spectators along its course every year. A men's Olympic marathon team selection race, this year's Tokyo Marathon will be an unusual spectacle with only 200 elite runners including national record holder Suguru Osako (Nike) and previous record holder Yuta Shitara (Honda).

The Tokyo Marathon Foundation is also looking at significantly cutting back the activities of the 11,000 volunteers involved in the event's operations. On Feb. 1 the Foundation already asked roughly 1,800 participants living in China to refrain from taking part…

Tokyo Marathon Looking at Cutting General Division in Response to Coronavirus (updated)

Update: The Tokyo Marathon's mass-participation race has been canceled. More information here.

It has been learned that the Tokyo Marathon Foundation is considering cutting back on the number of runners in the Mar. 1 Tokyo Marathon in response to the continued spread of the coronavirus. According to a spokesperson, the Foundation is said to be considering options including reducing the number of participants and completely canceling the mass participation race.

The Tokyo Marathon has the largest number of participants of any marathon in Japan, with around 40,000 people entered for this year's race. As an Olympic selection race for men, the elite field in Tokyo this year includes national record holder Suguru Osako and previous national record holder Yuta Shitara.

The Foundation and metropolitan government had previously announced plans to distribute masks to runners who wished to use them. But in light of the continued spread of the coronavirus after that announcement, discuss…

Nagoya Women's Marathon Considering Canceling Mass Participation Race

In the wake of the Tokyo Marathon's cancelation of its mass-participation race, on Feb. 17 it was learned that the Mar. 8 Nagoya Women's Marathon, which like Tokyo features a format combining an elite selection race for the 2020 Olympic team with a mass-participation race, is examining whether it will be possible to still stage the mass-participation component of its event.

Following the Tokyo Marathon's announcement earlier in the day that it was canceling its mass-participation race over concerns about the spread of the coronavirus, Nagoya's organizers were inundated with inquiries from the media and amateur runners entered in the race. The organizers say that they hope to reach a decision and make an announcement as soon as possible.

The largest women-only marathon in the world, as of Feb. 13 Nagoya has 24,002 entrants total this year, 137 in its elite division and 23,865 in its general division. Along with Nagoya, organizers are also examining the feasibility of s…